View Full Version : [VOTING] Standards King Ulrik Flamebeard August 22nd, 2007, 01:21 The following is all those who entered....
http://web.mac.com/alexpape7/iWeb/Site/standard_files/IMG_2104.jpg
Kossolax_the_Foresworn
http://i101.photobucket.com/albums/m61/irabradford/P8010046.jpg
Ira
http://img252.imageshack.us/img252/8132/120807001comp3vr2.jpg
Jon Quixote
http://www.librarium-online.com/showcase/files/1/1/1/9/0/BAstandard01.jpg
Kristofer
http://i34.photobucket.com/albums/d135/danjones87/IW/DSCF0043-1.jpg
danjones87
http://www.librarium-online.com/showcase/files/1/7/1/0/1/smallraven1copy.JPG
http://www.librarium-online.com/showcase/files/1/7/1/0/1/smallraven2copy.JPG
Cadaver Junkie
http://i37.photobucket.com/albums/e99/InquisitorEarl/acieris-banner-dude1.jpg
http://i37.photobucket.com/albums/e99/InquisitorEarl/acieris-banner-dude-montage.jpg
Inquisitor Earl
http://i190.photobucket.com/albums/z191/Leech-man/Random%20models/Standard1.jpg
http://i190.photobucket.com/albums/z191/Leech-man/Random%20models/Standard2.jpg
Leech
http://i147.photobucket.com/albums/r312/mpdscott/FlagellantStandard.jpg
mpdscott
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v163/minus-t/standardbearer/standardbearer_finished.jpg
minus_t
http://i20.photobucket.com/albums/b240/peacetalksandbattlecries/nerdery/photosuck.jpg
Sophia LordLink August 22nd, 2007, 01:32 minus_t that banner looks freaking awesome. I have no idea how hard/easy it is to paint but its the effect that counts and that looks brilliant.
danjones I like your guy too and I was going to vote for him until I saw minus_t's. Aether-Moose August 22nd, 2007, 01:55 I agree, that banner is insane! Awesome freehand, and the model itself is great too! :party: Leech August 22nd, 2007, 02:05 My vote goes to minus_t. The work on this banner is very good. I find the 3D effect is very well done. It gives alot to look at and the work on the gas-giant planet is especially good. The model is good too, I like the pose. Plus the details and the good highlights deserve respect, black is hard to highlight. Omnius August 22nd, 2007, 02:28 Well, I think that painting a freehand banner is the most difficult part of miniature painting, so all of you that entered already get my respect. I only have the one vote though, and it went to Ira. Good job you guys.
*Edit* minus_t's was just too good so it got the boot automatically :) Ira August 22nd, 2007, 02:59 I voted for Minus-t because, g-dd-mn, thats some golden demon quality stuff right there. Lost Nemesis August 22nd, 2007, 03:00 -t is only getting slightly fewer votes than if he had actually done Karmoon's face... :) Alas, my vote also goes to -t. That banner looks wicked, and the freehand on the model itself is very, very nice. theyak August 22nd, 2007, 03:07 -t, my friend... you should probably be banned from entering these contests. :)
I only say that out of jealousy of course. Fantastic freehand. Simply fantastic. DavidVC04 August 22nd, 2007, 03:15 Well, Earl had my vote until I scrolled down and saw Minus_T's work.
Still, many nice entries that make me envious. One thing I haven't learned to do is paint standards. Stonehambey August 22nd, 2007, 03:29 I like Ira the best. That savage Orc looks awesome! :) Killswitch August 22nd, 2007, 03:51 -t....-t.....-t....you have really done it this time... Only one thing to do....;? oh and :drinking:
-J BrianBlessed August 22nd, 2007, 04:20 minus-t's banner is great. It's a shame that it doesn't have anything to do with space marines. Codicier_Korsai August 22nd, 2007, 04:29 minus-t's banner is great. It's a shame that it doesn't have anything to do with space marines.
Drop pods are a trademark item of Space Marines! :)
I too went for -t's model who is rather masterful at these contests. The Blood Angels banner could have gotten alot more votes if more of the banner faced the camera, a textured base would have done it a favour too, the banner still murders anything I've tired. Rabbit August 22nd, 2007, 06:17 I cast my vote for -T. It seemed the popular thing to do. I wanted to vote for Leech as well. mpdscott August 22nd, 2007, 07:49 I had to vote for Ira's rather imaginative Orc Standard.
While -t's Marine was insanely good, it kind of ruined the whole "competition" thing :P
On a side note.....I got a vote? ;? Helbrecht August 22nd, 2007, 08:19 Woot! T got another Black Dragon done! Sweet banners all. Sir Theobold the Lame August 22nd, 2007, 09:04 im going with the throng and voting for minus -t, thats very very good freehand my friend- it reminds me of the huge banners people used to add onto their Golden Demon entries in the mid 90s. As we say in north wales, Splendudno
There were a lot of other entries i liked, in particular Leech and Ira's, Leech may have got my vote apart from the fact i hate that mini, the paint job is great but ive never liked that guy! Jon Quixote August 22nd, 2007, 09:53 There are three really 'high Standard' (sorry, I had to HAD TO get that in there) models that could get my vote.
Earl, Leech and -T.
Unfortunately, I have to vote for Minus. Even though in July he had the look of Old Nick about him.
I swear, those freehands aren't the first real attempt made by a man with his soul intact.
Begrudgingly, I await next month so that I can try even harder to not beat him. Karmoon August 22nd, 2007, 10:19 guuh.. for me personally, it's between Ira, Leech and -T...
Leech's actual figure is probably the best there....
but -T's banner is literally a work of art...
Gaaaah! *brain explodes* maraschino August 22nd, 2007, 11:31 good entries everyone :happy: USB turntable August 22nd, 2007, 12:00 I too liked the savage orc.
In my opinion, it was Leech who took my vote, as the entry felt very realistic and 'worn'. I prefer to see models that look realistic (the model reminded me of the soldiers in Joan of Arc, 1999) than seeing one that is beautifully painted.
Minus-t, you would have had my vote, but felt that you would have won anyway for the banner, and so Leech's got my vote for being a realistic looking model (Leech's was more realistic overall in my opinion, sorry). As I've said before, the dull black of the marine helps to move the attention on the superb freehand banner, but I would have liked to have seen a better colour scheme for the marine. Personal preference and all, which I felt would have been better.
:D minus_t August 22nd, 2007, 12:01 Well, I kinda don't know what to say...
Thanks everyone! I'm glad you like him ^_^
I'm gonna do my traditional run down of entires, and let y'all know who I voted for.
Koss:
Pretty nice, decent TT standard, though a tad ink-heavy for my personal tastes. I wouldn't dream of knocking your ability to get loads of stuff painted very fast (!), but it would be nice to see you spending a little more time on a model.
Ira:
Looks great, I like that the savage orcs haven't really made their own banner, just 'modified' a chaos one... =D I think the 'rock' on his club could do with a little more work, and a better photo would really help.
Jon Quixote:
Well, what can I say about my mode... Oh wait.
That's not my model! You b*****d!
Teehee. Very nice mate, though the photos let it down (very over-exposed, too much strong light, and not terribly good angles, IMO). How much of it is scratch-built/converted? The torso doesn't look quite 'standard' (if you will excuse the pun)...
Kristopher:
The standard looks fantastic, although I'm not really a fan of the metallics on it (seems like a 'real' use of NMM to me!). The rest of the model is slightly less good, IMO, and a little ink-heavy.
I like the helmet, but I'm not sure it 'goes' somehow...
Also, make sure you base things! I think I remember you posting this up as WIP, so maybe you've already done this =)
danjones87:
Lovely idea, and most of the model looks great, but I would like to see a bit more contrast in the flesh areas, as well as picking out those service studs!
The standard itself looks nice, but I think your paint is a bit thick.
Cadaver Junkie:
Looks really nice IMO. Great use of bitz, especially like the Terminator 'shield' attached to the forearm (combat shield?).
Great work on the greys/whites, but I think I'd like to see a more impressive banner, considering that this is a 'standard' contest =P
Also, I know you were rushed, but it would be nice to have some better pics, I suspect these don't do it justice.
Inquisitor Earl:
Fantastic work here. The freehand is very nice indeed.
The photos leave a bit to be desired, with some slightly odd crops; and the whole model is a bit glossy for my tastes, but nothing that can detract from the obvious quality of the job.
Leech:
Very nice indeed, as I have come to expect from you :C
Really nice, characterful model, with a paint job that makes him look like a grizzled, veteran career soldier, which is who I'd entrust my standard to!
I think I'd like to see the reds on the banner be a little brighter, as they are overpowered by the whites, IMO. But that is probably personal taste...
mpdscott:
Good TT standard, but hella-glossy (which I really don't like).
Also, the base is rock! Why is the rim green? Argh! =P
minus_t:
Well, what can I say about my own mode...
Oh wait. No, this one is mine. Phew, I was sure I had entered!
Well, I'm very happy with my first shot at any kind of detailed freehand...
My personal favorite bit is the initials on the purity seals on the banner, which reference the prank I played on those who frequent my painting blog... JK! =P
Spohia:
Looks good from what I can see, but to be honest, that isn't much...
Which is a shame, 'cos I love the Scythes of the Emperor, and the model looks interesting.
So, after all that, I'm going to vote for Leech.
It was a tough choice between him and Inquisitor Earl, but I think Leech's is overall of slightly better quality, and the freehand just seems more characterful to me.
Good work everyone, it's great to see so many good entires, and thanks again to everyone who has said nice things about my mini =)
-t. Jon Quixote August 22nd, 2007, 12:33 Jon Quixote:
Well, what can I say about my mode... Oh wait.
That's not my model! You b*****d!
Teehee. Very nice mate, though the photos let it down (very over-exposed, too much strong light, and not terribly good angles, IMO). How much of it is scratch-built/converted? The torso doesn't look quite 'standard' (if you will excuse the pun)...
Crappy photos, I could only get the extremes, either over exposed or under exposed. Grr.
Arms, one old school, one new loyalist.
Legs, old school loyalist. Both broken in half, removed at the joints, bent, GSed et c.
Torso, CHAOS marine.
Head, old loyalist, eyes cut out (I had to they were messed up) then refilled with GS.
Power pack, Chaos with the extensions trimmed out.
Bolter, old school loyalist with the mag removed.
Standard bottom, toothpick with a plastic bit on the bottom.
Standard top, Brettonian lance.
Tube, guitar wire.
Icons, Green stuff.
That's about it. :D mpdscott August 22nd, 2007, 13:31 mpdscott:
Good TT standard, but hella-glossy (which I really don't like).
Also, the base is rock! Why is the rim green? Argh! =P
I don't like the insane level of glare either, but for some unknown reason, the matt finish varnish I used didn't matt finish :/
As for the rim of the base....wasn't thinking :P not really an excuse, but still the truth. Probably would have brought out the greenery sitting infront of/underneath the rock too, oh well.
Next contest's my contest :P Jon Quixote August 22nd, 2007, 14:16 Next contest's my contest :P
I'll wrestle you for it.
*Gets out the olive oil.*
:D minus_t August 22nd, 2007, 14:24 *mind boggles*
*reaches for photoshop...*
Bwahahahahahah!
-t.
PS. Only if you really irritate me.
Just remember, the threat's there... ^_- Jon Quixote August 22nd, 2007, 14:44 (off topic, sorry)
Beat you to it.
http://img250.imageshack.us/img250/1377/ist21473775retroweightlyy7.jpg minus_t August 22nd, 2007, 14:46 *asplodes*
LOL!
Jon, you sir, are a genius!
-t. divineauthority August 22nd, 2007, 15:41 Minus_t's is too good. Nuff said :p
So I voted for Earl's, even then it was a hard choice between that and eech's but I went for Earl's in the end. Ancalagon August 22nd, 2007, 15:56 Well, it looks like we're going to have a very close finish here...:D
I just had to add my vote to the collection that minus_t has amassed - that banner is just too darned good.
Great job everyone. paul_Harkonen August 22nd, 2007, 18:03 Now that I have picked my jaw up off the floor (man do I need to sweep) I can comment on the entries.
First of all, I was going to vote for Ira until I saw -t's entry (sorry, it's just so amazing I have to vote for it), I really like the ork and the banner, it's a nice model.
That would be followed by Earl's model, who looked awesome, but for some reason the weathering you did, (to me) seemed too... splotchy. It looked less like real weathering, and more like just spots of random paint. It's still a damn impressive model though.
And third would be Leech's. I really liked the model, but the picture was a bit too... pink, for me. I don't know how much photoshopping occurred, or if the "pinkness" was intentional or not, but for me it made it harder to really tell how good the model was. It looks impressive, but the pinkish overtones make it seem kinda dull.
As a last word, There are several good entries, and it's almost a shame that -t's model is in this contest as that thing is just so impressive and so well done that it's difficult to compete with it. Sophia August 22nd, 2007, 19:06 -T, hands down. The theme of the banner is the only thing that detracts from it, IMHO a hero decapitating an ork or something would be more fitting, but as it is, the skill there easily outclasses everyone else by far.
I liked Cadaver Junkie's second best- the base in particular sets it off rather well, although it really didn't have much of a banner, which is why I didn't vote for it. Cyric the Mad August 22nd, 2007, 19:30 Look! A bandwagon *jumps*
Anyway, there are a lot of fine entries in this contest to be sure. I'm especially fond of Ira's savage orc - it is very nicely done.
However, -t takes this one without a doubt. I'm completely floored by that banner, and in awe of your skill, sir. Hats off, to be sure. Leech August 22nd, 2007, 19:44 "Hmmm" I wonder who's going to win? You really can't tell.
I shouldn't be so messy, sarcasim doesn't work in print.
I think the entries were good this time. Overall a good standard, pardon the pun. Taking part and doing a standard for me was fun as I rarely ever do them being a Tyranid nut and the Bugs don't have banners. I hope others enjoyed it. chemicalcaveman August 22nd, 2007, 20:09 Gah....
great job everyone, but -t's free hand effort is just mind blowing. He gets my vote. Koss August 22nd, 2007, 20:46 Koss vs. Minus T. Who will win... Find out next time on DragonBall-Z!!!:D
(p.s. Did anyone else notice how there would be like one small plot advance in that show like every three episodes and the rest was them just fighting really fast, and they would always say "wait until next time to see what happens" after you just watched half an hour of nothing but blurred kung fu.) minus_t August 23rd, 2007, 11:31 The only time I ever watched DragonBall Z was literally half an hour of watching various people standing looking agro, with those mental, flashing backgrounds, and their lips and/or pupils shuddering. No fighting (or anything else) took place.
Maybe it was one of the 'plot' episodes...
-t. The Paint Monkey August 23rd, 2007, 13:43 I voted -t. He made me feel better about not getting around to entering. :) Jon Quixote August 23rd, 2007, 14:46 While I voted -t, if I had the power, I would have vetoed him. King Ulrik Flamebeard August 23rd, 2007, 22:33 It appears that minus_t has cheated by being too good. Thus, by the power invested in me by Greyskull, I hereby remove him and his entry from existence. Carry on.
=P
KU Koss August 23rd, 2007, 22:38 It appears that minus_t has cheated by being too good. Thus, by the power invested in me by Greyskull, I hereby remove him and his entry from existence. Carry on.
=P
KU
Good one:rofl mpdscott August 24th, 2007, 07:52 I think I'm going to have to ask the people who've voted for my Flagellant to PM me, to explain their reasoning, it's not that good....
I'm not discarding the votes, I'm just unsure why mine rated higher than some of the others. theyak August 27th, 2007, 18:10 Jeese. C'mon people, let's see if we can't get -t 100 votes. ;) Ira August 29th, 2007, 05:55 thanks for the positive comments everyone. you can bet that i will be ready for next months contest.
speaking of future contests, when is the terrain category going to come around? I have a bunch of terrain to paint but no motivation do actually do it! Jon Quixote August 29th, 2007, 09:28 Ira, the previous winner gets to choose the next category, so, if you want to paint terrain *that* badly, you'll just have to paint whatever -t chooses *that* well to win!
I already have a couple of ideas if I won. In the unlikely event of JQ winning, oxygen masks will fall from the overhead compartment, there is a life jacket under your seat and the exits are here, here and here. Inquisitor Earl August 29th, 2007, 09:52 Yay I got second! Excellent job -t, you well deserve your amazing lead in first place. When I first saw karmoons face on that banner i thought 'how on earth did he paint that?', your actual banner was just as good though ;).
Thanks to everyone who gave me comments, they all help me to do better. I second Ira's idea for terrain. It's up to you -t though. Can't wait for the next one, it's been great fun.
Inquisitor Earl. minus_t August 29th, 2007, 11:06 Again, cheers very much everyone!
I'd better be a'thinkin' of a new contest theme then, hadn't I?
*puts thinking hat on*
*smokes pipe*
-t. Cyric the Mad August 29th, 2007, 13:12 Congrats, Mister T. A well-earned victory. Looking forward to the next one. Koss August 29th, 2007, 17:50 Again, cheers very much everyone!
I'd better be a'thinkin' of a new contest theme then, hadn't I?
*puts thinking hat on*
*smokes pipe*
-t.
you better pick chaos lords... or else... or else what?... exactly.:P King Ulrik Flamebeard August 29th, 2007, 18:49 Well, as we can see this was not a close race. With the run away win, is minus_t. His image will be added to the halls. So mate, if you want to grab me sometime soon, I'll be able to discuss a new theme with you. =)
As to the terrain contest. This is painting, for miniatures only. Scenery is another forum, you may set one up there if you wish but it will not feature in this contest. Single mini's only. Sorry.
KU | |