IRON CHEF VI: BOG ROLL BASH - Vote Thread

[Shonuff]

Here we go...number 6, vote time!

Librarium- Online's IRON CHEF: SCENERY VI : The Bog Roll!


Artificially Enhanced PROMETHIUM PLANT (http://www.librarium-online.com/forums/scenery/170737-iron-chef-scenery-vi-signups-7.html#post1504803)




Avatar of Khain TYRANID RECLAMATION POOL (http://www.librarium-online.com/forums/scenery/170737-iron-chef-scenery-vi-signups-7.html#post1504863)




Triple Threat OIL PIPELINE (http://www.librarium-online.com/forums/scenery/170737-iron-chef-scenery-vi-signups-7.html#post1504956)





Bugbait_nz 40K TOWER (http://www.librarium-online.com/forums/scenery/170737-iron-chef-scenery-vi-signups-6.html#post1504464)



Matus OLD SCHOOL TAVERN (http://www.librarium-online.com/forums/scenery/170737-iron-chef-scenery-vi-signups-6.html#post1504473)



Charger450 OYL REFILL STASHUN (http://www.librarium-online.com/forums/scenery/170737-iron-chef-scenery-vi-signups-6.html#post1504711)

[aussiedave]

I was really torn between the last three. The tower, the building and Fuel station. They are all three just excellent, but I went with the Tower. It's really well built, excellently painted and the control section just looks really darned cool.

Great job by all though.

Dave

[Guant]

I voted for the tower. But the refinery plant really came out nice with the final run of paint

[kevin vanrooyen]

I voted for the tower, but the oil pipeline was a close second, and the old school tavern a closer third.

[ShotgunFacelift]

Tough choice between the tower and the tavern as both did alot of work to ensure that the building materials were not immediatly obvious.

Went with the tower out of personal perference for style and painting

[miasma]

The tower was the clear winner for me, but I was most impressed by the old school tavern. Also anything orky is right up my alley, especially the cool red arrow pointing to it! Orks need direkshuns.

Well fought, Iron Chefs!

[jammer397]

i voted the Oyl Refill Stashun. the way it was painted too looked great. it looked orky and would work great for objectives.

the taven is very good too. the way he laid out the bottom half was just awesome.

the tower was also very good but i have seen so many towers that by now they all look the same.

the petro plant looked cool but i would say it still needs work.

the tyranid reclamation pool was different but just didnt catch my eye.

the pipe line was a good start but has a lot to be done yet before i would call it finished.

[charger450]

The Tower and Tavern both look great.

Bugbait’s tower is unbelievably good, but simple is design. It’s the kind of project that could easily be made into a pattern. It’s also painted very well, clearly imposing but aged, as if it has stood for many years. I also like the wire ladder rungs.
For some (very humble) critique, The seam where the two rolls meet on the column stand out, and the very top of the tower sits slightly off. It’s still a great piece.

Matus’ old school tower is also excellent, from the wood slats on tan plaster, the shingles, to the wooden door. What really stands out for me is the subtle but very well executed windows. Whether intentional or not, they have the look of old and dirtied glass. This is an all around great piece
One critique for you though, is the well. As nice as the stonework is on the outside, the inside looks to smooth.

My vote is going to go to Matus on this one; I really like the look of the tavern. While I’d love to have either piece in my collection, only one of them can get my vote. I may also be a little partial to the tavern because I have always loved that style of architecture.

Good show!

[Demon in White]

I voted the 40K Tower, it's brilliant :D

Although it was a toss-up between that and the Promethium Plant.

~ DiW

[Shonuff]

OKay Bug...
that's two in a row...you think you got it in you for a three-peat?

[bugbait_nz]

@ Shonuff, Ill have a bash, although I dont like my chances, too many good terrain builders around!

Thanks to all the people who voted!

@charger450, I agree with the gap between sections, wasnt that apparent until painted, I was hoping that it wouldnt get noticed!! will fix it up when I do the flooring.

Bugbait out

[ArtificiallyEnhanced]

Congrats Bugbait. I'll get you next time!

I can't wait for the next one actually, I've been keeping my hand in and have almost finished another 2 pieces! When does the next one start?

[Shonuff]

i'll set it up friday..
have one week for signups..
two weeks to build..

then voting.

[ArtificiallyEnhanced]

Sweet. I'm looking forward to it!

[matus]

Well done bugbait, well deserved, and well done everyone else :D