Welcome to Librarium Online!
Join our community of 80,000+ members and take part in the number one resource for Warhammer and Warhammer 40K discussion!
Registering gives you full access to take part in discussions, upload pictures, contact other members and search everything!
This was a in another topic that was kinda going astray. I decided it was more appropriate in it's own thread.
I see the Inquisition (Ordo Maleus and Hereticus) as the ONLY "Good Guys" in 40K. They fight the worst menace the Universe has. They fight it in the ONLY way possible.
With Chaos there ARE no "shades of grey" It's ONLY black or white. If you aren't actively opposing them.. you are facilitating them... you ARE them.
There's no such thing as 'a little bit Chaos' any more than there's 'a little bit pregnant'
It's an all or nothing game.
The Ordo's all ready have all of the material needs they could want. And those whom hoarde it are castigated and prosecuted (and normally executed) by their bretheren...
ONLY the fight against Chaos matters. The only 'REAL' Schism between Inquisitors is the 'Radical -vs- Puritan' thing... but they BOTH are all about black and white judgements.
Not sure it there IS a similar group to the Spanish Inq... If there were they would likely be some Governor's Arbites. But NOT the Holy Inquisition!
There are no EASY good guys in 40K... But the Ordo's are the 'hard'' good guys...
The Inquisition isn't as nice as you think, entire worlds will be put to the torch if the inquisitor in charge thiks the taint is there and there's no more way to rescue them.
AS for good guys the only good guys are the guys on your side, chaos marines consider themself good, most of them are doing it because they felt betrayed by the imperium or are helping mankind survive to horrors of the universe by bringing them into chaos.
I believe the term you may be looking for is anti hero, the worst type of hero as it makes all the bad guys look soft.
The =][= are not good guys as all the branches (you forgot the ordo xenos) have puritan and radical sides. Granted thier all, in the end, meant to help the Imperium in the long run (ends justify the means) but you've always got the ones that go rouge.
Its all about perspective when asking who are the good guys. Tau arnt far off but its a bit too Utopian for my liking (all that glitters...). Proberly the closest are orks as they are neither good or bad just out to do some stompin!!!!
I hear and I forget, I see and I remember, I do and I understand
Success is the ability to go from failure to failure without losing your enthusiasm.
It's quite simple really -
The imperium ( Imperial guard, sisters of battle and inquisition), is a facist dictatorship, that mercilessly crushes all rebellions and kills soldiers for cowardice. They also sacrifice millions of innocent people everyday to sustain the emperor, and even though yes it does stop the forces of chaos over running the galaxy, the end doesn't justify the means. They are also heavily xenophobic and will often destroy peaceful alien races simply out of spite.
Even the space marines follow these to some degree or another.
In short Imperium = Evil.
The eldar are an incredibly arrogant race who sacrifice millions of humans and other races instead of fighting themselves, they are also responsible for the creation of the chaos god slaneesh. The dark eldar are slightly worse as they kill, maime and torture millions in order to buy slaaneshes favour and stop him/her (he is both) from killing them.
So yeh eldar = Evil.
The tyranids and orks are more like diseases than anything else, they eat away at the galaxy (literally in the case of the tyranids) it is just the way they are, they are not necesarily evil but are by no means good.
The Necrons are enslaved to the C'tan, the C'tan are evil plain and simple, and the necrons made the deal that has enslaved them in order to take revenge upon the old ones so again evil.
Chaos... do i even need to say anything... EVIL, just incase that isn't satisfactory think sacrifices, killing more killing more sacrifices did i mention killing and sacrifices. All of which is for personal power. There are a couple of chaos factions which have background that suggests good but none of it is a complete certainty, example = alpha legion. They supposedly joined with Horus in an attempt to destroy chaos entirely, sacrificing themselves and the rest of humanity to save the entire universe. While it failed it was if true a very selfless act.
Tau i would say are the only race that fights for a good cause. They fight for what is effectively, equality and peace for all. They fight to expand there way of life. They fight those who fight back and allow innocents to join there empire in exchange for its protection.
So yeh i'd say Tau are the only good race in 40k. Out of the main ones and those that are still alive anyway.
Last edited by unholyheretic; December 6th, 2008 at 17:48.
Warning this user is totally insane...
Lol on the same logic the Tau are manipulative socialists abused and used by the strange powers of the Ethereals
As for the Eldar humans are like cattle to them. Manipulating humans to take the brunt of attacks is less twisted than you killing a cow to make a Burger. (not that im trying to encourage vegetarism its just the how I see the Eldars perspective on humans). Ok the Eldar created Slaneesh but at least the regret it.
The Imperium of Man has nice intentions, I would not say it is evil as it stand, howeverbe it is a bit of an open market for abuse by those who are.
Some of the Space Marines are pretty much pinnacles of good. Blood Angels for example are virtuous and noble in ideal. Though they do let the humans of Baal suffer abit. Then there are the Space Wolves who have lofty ideals, though again they don't do anything to improve the life of the ruled planets population so they are tough. A greater good paralell maybe. The Salamanders maybe, can't think of any reason of hand why they are Evil.
Tau are kindof like the Chinese Government. Looking out for the betterment of it's society and it's indivuduals, as long as it doesn't oppose the Communist party.
The only pure good force (to it's own morality) is a Puritan Grey Knight force. There has never been one Grey Knight that has turned.
"A love for tradition has never weakened a nation, indeed it has strengthened nations in their hour of peril."
Sir Winston Churchil
Destroying a world full of people.. Innocent people.. So that they are not corrupted and become part of the Enemy.. Is sometimes an appropriate response... In the scope of a BILLION Worlds.. what's one.. or a hundred.. or a thousand... or a hundred thousand.. Keeping weapons out of the arsenal of Chaos is more important.Some do.. I think most (especially the 'cult' types) are only in it for their own good and the good of their Gods... i.e. Evil.AS for good guys the only good guys are the guys on your side, chaos marines consider themself good, most of them are doing it because they felt betrayed by the imperium or are helping mankind survive to horrors of the universe by bringing them into chaos.heh.. anti-hero's aren't really heroes beyond 'the enemy of my enemy' kind of wayI believe the term you may be looking for is anti hero, the worst type of hero as it makes all the bad guys look soft.I didn't forget the OX.. THEY aren't part of the 'anti Chaos' forces I consider the 'good guys' . and I wasn't talking about individuals... you will always find good/bad persons.. I was talking about organizations..The =][= are not good guys as all the branches (you forgot the ordo xenos) have puritan and radical sides.Yeah... when they put on makeup.. they are certainly veering toward Slanneshi.Granted thier all, in the end, meant to help the Imperium in the long run (ends justify the means) but you've always got the ones that go rouge.Those Commies???? Talk about EVIL... and they have NO defenses in general against the incursions of Chaos... Wipe 'm out for OUR own good!Its all about perspective when asking who are the good guys. Tau arnt far off but its a bit too Utopian for my liking (all that glitters...).Them 'n the Tyranids.. Food for the Food God!!!Proberly the closest are orks as they are neither good or bad just out to do some stompin!!!!
Pure in motives.. but not really 'Good' either one.
chinese government don't take individuals into account. They treat everyone equally.
I'm not sure about Tau, immune to Chaos and allies with Daemons?
True grey Knights have morality, but their faith is too strong to question the creed of the Imperium. What if the creed is imorale in places?
Orks are in the fight for themselves. They don't recognise civilisation and don't build towards the future.
Eldar know too much, they simply cannot complete all their technological assessts because they have too few, for many have fallen to other powers. They simply cannot build harmony.
Similar to Eldar, humans fall too easy to the enemy. They need leadership, unlike Eldar which means, they ultimately have the power to become good guys.
I might write like a ork but i fight like a poet.
Some one tell me they have ever seen a nightbringer die from a Nemesis Force Weapon.