Welcome to Librarium Online!
Join our community of 80,000+ members and take part in the number one resource for Warhammer and Warhammer 40K discussion!
Registering gives you full access to take part in discussions, upload pictures, contact other members and search everything!
If it's a fashion/"How cool do I look?" duel, Darth Vader wins with little effort.
In a combat scenario however, Gandalf would beat Vader. He is older, has more combat experience and has fought the darkests things in his univerese. "Just a Balrog" was not just a Balrog. Balrogs were ancient terrors that even predated Sauron [contemporary to Shelob], their power was rivaled only by dragons and they served Morgoth [Sauron was just Morgoth's lackey and see how much everyone feared HIM]
After Episode III came out [becoming Star Wars canon], Darth Vader's cowning achievement was to slaughter younglings. When confronted by a fully trained Jedi [Obi-Wan] he ended up in life support.
The force choke has some merit, but Gandalf can easily hurl a fireball at Vader and make him loose concentration like Luke did [when he pointed a steaming pipe/hose (not sure if it was hot or cold steam) at Vader, that was enough for him to back off (See their duel at Bespin for reference)]
Before episodes I, II and III, Vader's line of "The ability to destroy a planet is insignificant next to the power of The Force." had a mystic weight to it, enhanced by his frightful apearance. Now, in my humble opinion, it's jus hot words form a whinny killer of children.
In nomeni Telum, et Flamma, Fervefacio. Ave Imperator!
"Short of Galactus [or a well placed, Force-guided X-Wing], the Death Star beats everything."
Not Chuck Norris... Nothing beats Chuck