Gandalf vs Vader

[Burnanation]

Simple, Gandalf vs Vader, who would win. I know who I would vote for and why but I want to see what other people say.

[Kabbala]

As a Maiar, Gandalf is essentially a lesser god. Vader would be sure to piss him off with some sort of force choke hold, and Gandalf would unleash his full power on him overloading his cybernetics, if not vaporizing him outright.

[insideprawn]

Vader with both magic and tech would win. Any of Gandalf's magic could be absorbed by Vader's saber.

[sithjack]

The power to destroy a planet is nothing compared to the power of the force.

I vote for that guy.

[lewbot1]

Vader all the way... first of all he would chop off Gandalf's hand THEN tell him what he did with his mother...

its just complete pwnage

[pilot00]

I vote for vader merely cause he is awsome looking and has a great and bitter story behind him thus i like him better.If he could meet gandalf the pink,erhm white he would have been pawned.

[Visitor Q]

Gandalf.

First of all his magic is stronger, he can destroy what ever Vader is standing on for starters.

Secondly he can back to life if his mission requires it.

If I remember correctly him coming back as Gandalf the white wasn't a one shot deal. in theory he could keep coming back if necessary.

Essentially you are dealing with an agent of God vs a powerful human.

Assuming God exists (which in this scenario we have to otherwise Gandalf is pointless) then Gandalf wins.

[carrotman50]

Really, all this boils down to is if you prefer Star Wars to LOTR............

.........Go Vader!

[visseking]

First off.

Is darth vader really a human...

I'd say no. He's an alien.

Second of all, darth vader died due to the strongest force in the world, while gandalf just got pawned by a balrog. And vader has the power (force) to live on as a ghost. Truly immortal. And that's pretty standard for jedis. To make a long story sgort. Gandalf would stand with a melted sword, without hands, or head, with about 7 20 tons boulders on hs head. And if he came back, hew would lie there again.

[Ancalagon]

First off.

Is darth vader really a human...

I'd say no. He's an alien.

Second of all, darth vader died due to the strongest force in the world, while gandalf just got pawned by a balrog. And vader has the power (force) to live on as a ghost. Truly immortal. And that's pretty standard for jedis. To make a long story sgort. Gandalf would stand with a melted sword, without hands, or head, with about 7 20 tons boulders on hs head. And if he came back, hew would lie there again.

What do you mean Vader is an alien? He's a human who happend to need bionic life support because of horrific injuries.

But you're forgetting that Gandalf (or Olórin to use his proper name) is truly immortal, not in the way that Vader sort of is. Gandalf is a Maia, who are the lesser of the Ainur, who are immortal spirits who entered Valinor at the beginning of time, and are essentially representitives of Eru Ilúvatar on earth.

[/Tolkien nerd]