Hi all, fairly new to the boards, but have browsed quite a bit before posting these two lists of mine that i'm trying to decide between for a friend's hombrew campaign.

The campaign requires that the army list be balanced enough to face all comers, (which atm include Marine, Necron, Nid, Tau and IG).

Please note that my troop selection has been (in part) influenced by my available models (rough outline of my eldar collection in toto is at the end of the post)

So, which is a better composition (in both cases, assume the farseer joins one of the larger guardian squads);

Army A

1500 Pts - Eldar Army

1 Farseer (HQ)
Witchblade (x1); Shuriken Pistol (x1)
Guide

1 Warlock Bodyguard
Singing Spear
Conceal

5 Warp Spiders (Elites)
Deathspinner

7 Striking Scorpions (Elites)
Mandiblasters; Shuriken Pistol & CCW
1 Exarch
Mandiblasters; Scorpion's Claw; Shuriken Pistol
Stealth

8 Guardian Storm Squad (Troops)
Shuriken Pistol & CCW (x6); Flamer (x1); Fusion Gun (x1); Blind Grenades;
Haywire Grenades
1 Warlock
Witchblade (x1); Shuriken Pistol (x1)
Enhance
1 Wave Serpent
Shuriken Cannon Upgrade; Linked Star Cannon

14 Guardian Defender Squad (Troops)
Shuriken Catapult

14 Guardian Defender Squad (Troops)
Shuriken Catapult
1 Warlock
Witchblade (x1); Shuriken Pistol (x1)
Conceal

5 Guardian Defender Squad (Troops)
Shuriken Catapult
2 Grav Platform & Crew
Shuriken Catapult (x2); Scatter Laser (x1)

1 Falcon Grav-Tank (Heavy Support)
Linked Shuriken Catapults; Bright Lance; Pulse Laser

1 Falcon Grav-Tank (Heavy Support)
Linked Shuriken Catapults; Bright Lance; Pulse Laser

1 Wraithlord (Heavy Support)
Flamer (x1); Shuriken Catapult (x1); Star Cannon

Models in Army: 64
Total Army Cost: 1499


or

Army B

1500 Pts - Eldar Army

1 Farseer (HQ)
Witchblade (x1); Shuriken Pistol (x1)
Guide

1 Warlock Bodyguard
Singing Spear
Conceal

5 Warp Spiders (Elites)
Deathspinner

7 Striking Scorpions (Elites)
Mandiblasters; Shuriken Pistol & CCW; Plasma & Haywire Grenades
1 Exarch
Mandiblasters; Scorpion's Claw; Shuriken Pistol; Plasma & Haywire
Grenades
Stealth

8 Guardian Storm Squad (Troops)
Shuriken Pistol & CCW (x7); Fusion Gun (x1); Blind Grenades; Haywire
Grenades

1 Warlock
Witchblade (x1); Shuriken Pistol (x1)
Enhance

1 Wave Serpent
Shuriken Cannon Upgrade; Linked Star Cannon

15 Guardian Defender Squad (Troops)
Shuriken Catapult

5 Guardian Defender Squad (Troops)
Shuriken Catapult

2 Grav Platform & Crew
Shuriken Catapult (x2); Scatter Laser (x1)

5 Guardian Defender Squad (Troops)
Shuriken Catapult

2 Grav Platform & Crew
Shuriken Catapult (x2); Scatter Laser (x1)

1 Vyper Squadron (Fast Attack)
Linked Shuriken Catapults (x1); Shuriken Cannon (x1)

1 Falcon Grav-Tank (Heavy Support)
Linked Shuriken Catapults; Bright Lance; Pulse Laser

1 Falcon Grav-Tank (Heavy Support)
Linked Shuriken Catapults; Bright Lance; Pulse Laser

1 Wraithlord (Heavy Support)
Flamer (x1); Shuriken Catapult (x1); Star Cannon

Models in Army: 58
Total Army Cost: 1499


[For those with too much time on their hands who'd like to design me a better multi-purpose list, here is a quick inventory of my game-ready eldar;

35 Guardians (inc grav crew)
2 scatter laser platforms, 1 missile platform
8 stormies
2 farseer, 2 warlock
avatar
3 jetbikes
1 vyper
2 falcon
1 wave serpent
1 fire prism (can double as 2nd wave serpent)
1 wraithlord
1 war walker
7 striking scopr
1 Karandras (who doubles as a SS exarch)
5 fire dragons
5 warp spiders
4 rangers

Stuff still on my workbench (which probably wouldn't be ready in time for campaign)
16 Dire avengers
10 swooping hawks
4 wraithguard
8 howling banshees]