Librarium Online Forums banner

if you could change one thing

710 views 12 replies 6 participants last post by  Cheredanine 
#1 · (Edited)
ok i got the idea for this of another warhammer website.

if you could change ONE THING about the codex what would it be. 1 sentence replies only. it would be great if every member who read it wrote just one thing
 
#2 ·
I'd change the veil of tears to behave more like shrouding, and I'd change Holofields to be more like their Epic representation (hit modifiers depending on move).
 
#8 ·
thats the whole idea to see what people think is wrong with the codex and how with think it could be improved
 
#9 ·
Why?

I appreciate that that sounds rather arguementative, it isnt personnal, my point is that it changes nothing, it appear to be posting for the sake of posting and this kind of post, plus the repeated polls, are diluting an otherwise excellent forum with pointless threads
 
#10 · (Edited)
not all the thready have to make the wargaming world a better place they just have to be intresting and they dont have ot be fresh its good to get a now view on things. and even if there are polls the same they are way back and most people wont go trauling to find them and its good to have some fresh stuff
 
#11 ·
Polls:
http://www.librarium-online.com/forums/eldar/100232-close-combat-squad.html
-what is the point of this?

http://www.librarium-online.com/forums/eldar/100217-phoenix-lords.html
- ditto?

http://www.librarium-online.com/forums/eldar/100070-hq.html
- ditto?

http://www.librarium-online.com/forums/eldar/95687-what-colour-scheme-do-you-use.html
- no point?

http://www.librarium-online.com/forums/eldar/83906-new-heavy-weapons-how-do-they-rank.html
-admitte4dly this one has something of a discusion to it so slightly better, but lets have the discussion then - why the poll?

I did not mean repeat as in someone has run them before, but repeated as in poll after poll which server little obvious purpose other than mild interest and increased post count, on the down side it dilutes the quality of the forum and posts in it. If there is to be a debate on something then lets by all means debate it. but lets not just post for the sake of it, is this making sense?
 
#12 ·
the bottem 2 are not mine so go and bite sombodie elses head off about them ok. the middle one helped me build me army which is, after all that this forums is about. isn't it? true the top 2 have slightly less point but we can post somthing bacause its intrresting, cant we? who cares about their post count, i most certianly dont. we cant all be angels like you Cheredanine
 
#13 · (Edited)
theeldarlord said:
the bottem 2 are not mine so go and bite sombodie elses head off about them ok.
no actualy i did not say they were, indeed I did say it wasnt something personnal to you and I promise you if I had bitten your head off you would know about it

I am not trying to attack you, I am trying to keep LO as one of the best forums around, and so am tryng to have a discusion with you and others, rather than just enforcing my own, subjective opinion

the middle one helped me build me army which is, after all that this forums is about. isn't it?
Indeed and the discusion is good, I can see why it helps you, but it doesnt need the poll and everyone chimming in critiquing the poll, they should be helping you rather than doing that,

true the top 2 have slightly less point but we can post somthing bacause its intrresting, cant we?
Erm yes- that is pretty much the rules of all forums and is actually what my point is, with over 20,000 members, and even just including the almost 3000 active members, if each of them only post one thread that is not interesting, every single forum on the board would contain a first page entirely made of non-interesting information, which would kind of make the forum non-interesting
who cares about their post count, i most certianly dont.
rather the problem is there are users who do, appreciate you say you dont, but clearly there are users who do
we cant all be angels like you Cheredanine
just to prove to you this aint personnal against you, nor any attempt to be agressive, I will ignore that swipe
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top