Librarium Online Forums banner
Status
Not open for further replies.

Analysis of Dark Eldar society

6.1K views 20 replies 14 participants last post by  Ravenscraig  
#1 ·
I don't know how many people play DnD or know about the Drow (dark elves) from that game, but I have always been a huge fan of them throughout my life (mostly teenage years). They are actually what led me to play Warhammer Dark Eldar and Dark Elves.

Anyways, I have been thinking and rethinking about the cultural, historical, societal, political and psychologycial aspects of Dark Eldar society. And the more I do, the more I find them to be alike the Drow.

Unlike Games Workshop's short, brief and totally half-assed creations of Dark Eldar society, all we can glimpse is a TINY fraction of what they are truly like. And worse of all, they are usually from the Imperium's point of view.

Therefore, I believe that it is my duty, as a Dark Eldar fanatic, to fully examine the society in which our beloved Dark Kin lives, to its fullest degree. Remember, this is all theoritical. However, it does include lots of information gleamed from the Fantasy Dark Elves, as well as the fantastically complex societal structures of the Drow from DnD. So, the question remains. Are the Dark Eldar the uncouth, brutal pirates of the 40k Universe? Or are they the lithe, cunning, and graceful terrors who stalk the shadows and kill with a subtleness and beauty that few others can match? I think it is the latter.

Dark Eldar Society

Dark Eldar society, although full of darkness, terror and vileness, is still purely from a Mon-Keigh point of view. What we view as vile, may simply be normal, everyday events to them. From looking at the Codex and conversing with various other DE players, I have concluded the following.

DE society is divided into at least 4 different Castes, if not more. There are the Kabals, no doubt making up the majority of the political aspect of Commorragh. They rule through fear, power play, subtlety, assassinations, and so on. The second are the Wych Cults. These are highly (extremely) skilled combatants, who train ceaselessly in the gladiatorial arenas. They are hired and used by the Kabals to carry out their ends, but oftentimes they persue their own ends as well. Third, there are the Haemonculi, and their insane experiments. They are the ones who create many of the strange weapons of the Dark Eldar, no doubt. Lastly, there have been talkings of "Incubi Sects" (which are not GW-sponsored fluff, from what I know), which are extremely reclusive, martial, and deadly warriors who will occasionally ally with Kabals and such in order to further their own cause. On the whole, DE society is filled with death and danger.

However, this does NOT make them uncouth, savage killers. These words are simply too "uncouth" to be applied to Dark Eldar, in my humble opinion. Who knows what goes on in Commorragh? No one yet -- however, my research and assumptions have led me to believe that Dark Eldar won't likely get their heads chopped off when they walk on the streets everyday. Dark Eldar are not, I repeat, bloodthirsty, psychotic servants of Khorne, nor are they the drug-induced, sex-obsessed servants of Slannesh. They are the Dark Eldar, something completely different, and yes, much more sophisticated lifeforms and culture than those two [Chaos cultures].

Like I said, a DE warrior won't likely get slaughtered for walking in the open. Why? Let's take a look at society in general. First, there will no doubt be some sort of political faction in control of the Dark City. The Kabals most likely represent Commorragh's nobility, the Dark Eldar Aristocracy. It is they who sets up law and order, albeit at a completely different level than what humans percieve. Without order, there can only be anarchy. While Dark Eldar revel in death and assassination, their very nature as exquisite, lithe Eldar will NO DOUBT lead them to a much more subtle appreciation of death, and they way it is performed. In the heat of battle, decapitation is fine, I guess. However, in the back alleys of Commorragh, why should such a thing occur! Such barbarity is unfit for the Dark Eldar. Why should they resort to such ancient methods of death, when poison, gas, or the complex procedure of various killing procedures leave so much more space for the beauty of death? For the Dark Eldar, killing is an ART. It is not enough to simply chop off an limb. No, killing must have value TO IT. The more creative and imaginative you are, the more you are appreciated, hated, and respected in Dark Eldar society.

This again brings me back to the very core of Dark Eldar psychology. They are STILL Eldar, evil or not. They APPRECIATE things of beauty. They APPRECIATE subtleness. They APPRECIATE complexity, craftsmanship, skill, talent, and all of those things. They appreciate good, tasteful food (souls, most likely). Why can't the Dark Eldar love things that have high materialist value? Why shoudln't the Dark Eldar surround themselves with beautiful, dark sculptures, masterly crafted jewelry, ancient, ornate blades, and exquisitely fine armour? To have any less would make them into the savage, uncouth, disgusting species of the Mon-Keigh, as vile as Chaos!!! A Dark Eldar will buy exquisite wine, fine clothing, and beautiful art, without giving a care for the price.

As for they fountains of skulls they take from their enemy, what of it? Why must the skulls remain rotten and disgusting? Who said the Dark Eldar do not have the best, most masterful craftsman created amazing works of art from the skulls and remains of their enemy, ornated with rare stones, metals, and other things we don't know about! Again, the battlefield is a disgusting place, that DOES NOT reflect the nature of Commorragh. Commorragh might be MUCH MORE CLEANER than your typical Imperial city, or even our world (Earth, ie America/England). They are Eldar after all. Who said experimenting for the Haemonculi is all they capture slaves for? This is absurd. The slaves no doubt are made to clean every grime and dirt off the street. Commorragh may be the city of darkness, of perpetual twilight, but it might as well be the damn cleanest place we've seen.

This is what I have gleamed so far of DE society. Next, I will post my assumptions/theories about their political structure, how it works, what kind it is (ie monarchy, democracy, etc), and eventually their form of economics (no doubt purely domestic, no mercantalism, although this might be untrue).

What I am trying to do is take a very find examination of how the Dark Eldar realm works. Thanks for reading, and I would appreciate any responses.

Infrazael Draennonssraav --

Your Fellow Incubi
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ebon Hand
Save
#2 ·
I completely agree with you infrazeal those mon keighs all look to the reports of there own ppl or captured DE but when you look to the hive cities.(That are rotten to the core and things like bionic ppl doesnt sound healthy to me) there alot worse then all the marble and silver you see in the pictures. i recently started to read the 40k fluff books and before reading I would have never thought about all the corruption infested ppl possesed filthy gasses etc etc that are within a hive city. Also the only part of fluff I know so far about something looking from the dark eldar vieuw is the tortuers tale givign us a whole different point of vieuw. Also the first book ive ever read about 40k was crimson tears a part in it also shows that De have taste. (The archon takes place in a beautifull palace laid with the rarest metals and gems)

I also agree on the savage way about killing. The kabals will most likely have something simulair to a inviseble border. If something passes it without reporting first or watever it will msot likely be shot down. (hellions will not chop the archons warriors down without permission imo) A archon wont tolerate savage murders on his streets from another kabal cult etc. Instead it would try to protect its warriors. (He needs them to raid with after all).

Also there are just minor pieces of text that say that not all slaves will be tortured or be used as ''soul food'' in some part of the codex a mon keigh states that the most humble and most ''cooperating'' mon keigh will be taken into ''protection'' of the hamos and will be learned the art of the hamos. It would be strange that warriors would whipe the floor while the archon has 20k slaves in his dungeon and not let those whipe the floor letting the warriors protect him instead.

I could talk on hours like this wat GW is forgetting to tell us or the major pieces of fluff we would like to see but I think were better of with just glimps of my thoughts instead of whole novels :p. I look forward to your next post about your thoughts about the DE.

-Archonbjorn-
 
Save
#3 ·
Some very interesting thoughts there, maybe GW could take some lessons off you, otherwise, I dont know what to add but to completely agree ;) , it seems you have summed things up pretty well, maybe we will get more of an insight when our shiny brand new codex comes out, I think when that happens, it will just prove how correct this thread is.
 
Save
#4 ·
Thanks for the replies.

I think I'm going to write some other things today, finish up the second part of my DE essay. It's going to be all about DE politics, what type of government they have, hierarchies, etc, etc.

Should be interesting.

Also, if you have any questions or think I have made mistakes/forgotten things, feel free to post them.
 
Save
#5 ·
I totally agree with you Infrazael. Its nice to see someone who appreciates the Dark Eldar so much as to dispel some of the myths about them. They say that the Dark Eldar are the true Eldar since their culture bears the closest resemblance to the original Eldar's culture before the fall. The image you put forth is therefore fitting, and personally its the way I've always viewed them ever since I became a fan of them.
 
Save
#6 ·
*Agreementized*. I think that the DE are in no way trully worse than the Imperium, I mean, the Imperium argues they use enemy's corpses for decoration, but isn't that on some way honouring the slain? Isn't it saying that for fighting they earned the right to be honoured in death? And the slave raids is just the same as what the Imperials would do if they found a traitor camp, is it not? They come in, either kill or drag off the traitors then force them to confess! At least the DE put them to some sort of use. And what of the horrors the Haemonculi commit? Well, is not the same thing done when turning a man into a space marine? And the DE (unlike the Imperium) do not simply produce killing machines for the purpose of death. Furthermore, wouldn't you feel a tad bit bitter if you had been invaded and attacked by the Imperium, maybe that explains their ruthlessness and hatred? One could still say the gladiatorial arenas the wyches fight in are barbaric, but they no doubt choose to fight with full knowledge of the consequences.
 
Save
#7 ·
i play a drow in my D&D group, <3 drow, even though the DM hates me and nearly kills me everytime we play. i noticed that they were similar to the DE, i even have my DE with white hair and black skin. thanks for the insight, will help when i explain DE culture to those imperium players
 
#8 · (Edited)
But what of the role of the Haemonculi in all this? I felt sure that it was their job to extract the souls of captured prisoners to help extend the life of the Dark Eldar, but this doesn't seem to take it into account.

And I can't help but remember something I got told a while back, that every Dark Eldar dies with a look of the most horrific terror on their faces. Surely the threat of Slaanesh should take its part in their society?
 
#9 ·
The Haemonculi are the torture experts. That does not contradict anything I've said.

They use mon-keigh and captured slaves as devices to conduct those experiments. . . . and what is wrong with that?

They could be just as hedonistic and narcissistic as the rest of the Dark Eldar. . . . . just more twisted.

BTW, you'd think they were sanitary enough to clean up after their own messes, wouldn't you?

Infrazael Draennonssraav,

Aspiring Incubus Grand Master
 
Save
#11 ·
Haemonculi are artists, the pain and suffering of thier victoms is thier medium. A painter can create beautiful images with a brush and some paint, a Haemonculi can enhance the quality of the souls they consume by inflicting creative new forms of pain and suffering on the creature bearing the soul.Even the gortesques and other creatures they create are just another product of thier art. They're like walking monuments to the art of inflicting pain. I'm a die hard servant of the Imperium, but that doesn't mean I haven't come to know and respect the ways of the Dark Eldar.I think ID has done a really good job of explaining the way they work.Can't wait to hear your explination of thier politics. ^_^
 
#13 ·
Xerxes said:
So how are the souls of other life-forms extracted then?
by killing them


Excellent work, I have sort of created somthing like this for my own kabal, and when i read the codex I find it insulting, so I have had to come up with a whole load of fluff to allow them to do this. Now I don't have to.

And the Dark Eldar look smart, no matter what kabal they are in. Their armour is perfect, their weapons are perfect, hell even their hair is perfect (front cover of the codex)
 
Save
#14 ·
The Forum Idiot said:
*Agreementized*. I think that the DE are in no way trully worse than the Imperium, I mean, the Imperium argues they use enemy's corpses for decoration, but isn't that on some way honouring the slain? Isn't it saying that for fighting they earned the right to be honoured in death?
The Dark Eldar by no means honor the dead when they stick them on Pikes and flaunt them at their enemies. I think they know what they are doing and what feeling they want to evoke, but to them it is nothing to be ashamed of. It is no different than a human carrying a rabbit's paw to rub for good luck. =)

The Forum Idiot said:
And what of the horrors the Haemonculi commit? Well, is not the same thing done when turning a man into a space marine? And the DE (unlike the Imperium) do not simply produce killing machines for the purpose of death. Furthermore, wouldn't you feel a tad bit bitter if you had been invaded and attacked by the Imperium, maybe that explains their ruthlessness and hatred?
The Space Marines aren't tortured to the very ends of pain when they become Space Marines, and plus they also do so by will. The Dark Eldar are also always the instigators in fights vs. the Imperium, seeing as they have almost no way to follow the cunning Dark Kin to their world. The Dark Eldar see the humans as nothing more than cattle, much in the same way as the Eldar do, though the Dark Eldar are much more open with it. It's basically the "better you than me" mentality.

However, I get the basic jist of what you are saying.

Who are the Humans to critisize the Dark Eldar's practices when they sacrifice thousands of each other to that weakling seer they call Emperor? Is that any different from the souls that the Lords suck up to slake their own thirst? At least the Dark Eldar are (for the most part) at peace with what they have become. The ignorant ones look on with disdain at that which they can't begin to understand.
 
Save
#15 ·
Just like to throw in my two cents about something that was brought up. Yes, the de are almost always portrayed through the eyes of the imperium. There is also very few *official* specifics on certain aspects of their culture and polotics. However, i do not believe this to simply be laziness on GW's part. In a weird way, they represent the imperium. Also, i believe that they mean to maintain the mystery part of the mysterious de. Anyway, thats all i got to say. I agree with the other stuff said.
 
Save
#16 ·
Commander Montka said:
Just like to throw in my two cents about something that was brought up. Yes, the de are almost always portrayed through the eyes of the imperium. There is also very few *official* specifics on certain aspects of their culture and polotics. However, i do not believe this to simply be laziness on GW's part. In a weird way, they represent the imperium. Also, i believe that they mean to maintain the mystery part of the mysterious de. Anyway, thats all i got to say. I agree with the other stuff said.
True, but it should be we DE players have enough intelligence to unfathom our own history, don't you agree? :p

peace,

Infrazael Draennonssraav,

Aspiring Incubus Grand Master
 
Save
#17 ·
Sorry for the long wait. Before this weekend, I will have the political aspect finished. After that, I'll delve into economics.

I will be adding to my ORIGINAL POST, so look there.

PS -- There will also be an Incubi story coming up. It is an attempt to delve into the sect of Incubi, and what they plan on doing. Should be good.
 
Save
#18 ·
well I have a question. its probably a stupid one but: what went wrong omong the Eldar that they have become "dark" :confused:
 
Save
#19 ·
Nothing went wrong the Dark Eldar are how the majority of Eldar were before the Fall. The Fall was the birth of Slannesh and She Who Thirsts has quite a liking for Eldar souls, now the Craftwolrd Eldar are a group who split away fromt he core of Eldar society and behave differently, they stil ahve the same lusts however and are just the same as the Dark Eldar underneath.
 
#21 ·
Perverted fiends!!! Quit making excuses for yourselves!!! Your only salvation lies in accepting the greater good!!!


OR DIE!!!!

*loads up rail gun*
Actually, this Thread was already well and truly dead until you woke it up again cocking your railgun in such an excitable fashion. So, power down your railgun, there's a good chap, and leave the dead to their well-earned rest.

++ Thread Closed ++

~ Raven ~
 
Save
Status
Not open for further replies.
You have insufficient privileges to reply here.