Librarium Online Forums banner
1 - 7 of 7 Posts

·
Banned
Joined
·
56 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Horus Rising: Fairly good, shows and explains alot of the story line. 7/10
False Gods: Improving on the story and much more action. 7/10
Galaxy In Flames: Intertwines with several other books a must read. 8/10
Flight of the Eisenstein: See the world threw one of the big players in the heresy the Death Guard: 8/10
Fulgrim: By far the most action and most enjoyable to read thus far, following the Emperors Children to there decent. 9/10
Descent of Angels: A look into the past when the Emperor was first finding the Primarchs. 6/10
Overall rating 8/10

With names like "Legion, Battle for the Abyss" we seem to be able to look foward to seeing much more fighting and seeing how far Horus will truely go.
 

·
Drills baby.
Joined
·
6,481 Posts
If you are going to rate books, talk a bit more about it! Tell us about the plot, the characters and how they evolve, themes or such things. At the moment this review is not very good at all since you don't explain a lot why you think about teh books like you do.

Please expand on it more.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
56 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·
If you are going to rate books, talk a bit more about it! Tell us about the plot, the characters and how they evolve, themes or such things. At the moment this review is not very good at all since you don't explain a lot why you think about teh books like you do.

Please expand on it more.
Nearly all books follow people you will rearly if ever hear about again, so to say Garro is in one or Travis is quite pointless. As well HATE spoilers
 

·
Drills baby.
Joined
·
6,481 Posts
You don't have to tell the entire plot, but the basic outline of it is always good to have. Haven't you done book reviews in school? Take them as examples.

My point is that you won't interest anyone by saying "This book is good read it 7/10".
A review that writes about the main characters, the plot and such things is far more interesting to read and will, without doubt, be more likely to influence a reader to pick up the book.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
4,800 Posts
Having read a couple of them I find the Horus Heresy books rather disappointing--sort of like reading a Greek tragedy you know the outcome of, but it doesn't work as well for sci-fi. There is nothing novel or interesting going on, really, just how the Heresy might reasonably have taken place. (Okay, the Eisenstein was one tough little frigate.) It really needs some subplots and plot twists, be a little less linear. I suppose the character delvelopment is good, given how Marines tend to have suppressed personality and individuality.

So why do I buy the books? :?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
28 Posts
in my opinion, if you've read the first book "horus rising" then you've read the the next three. why do I say that? the following three are basiclly the same story but substitute main characters/legions. well actually the first was probably the best that I've read so far, having read up to Eisenstien! I a little afraid to read any further for fear of reading the same story over again!
 

·
Skeletor=Pimp.
Joined
·
996 Posts
So far I am loving the novels, though I do have a few problems with it:

1. Primarch awe- After about the sixth time I read about a Space Marine in awe of a primarch I was fed up with it, listen writers we get it, the primarchs are like jesus christ in power armour, stop forcing it down our throats.

2. Repetitive story- The Isstivan III massacre has happened multiple times now, and like many others on here I'm a bit passed it. Luckily the next few books are away from the massacre and are moving forward so I look forward to improvement.

Really my only two complaints, the character development and battles along with a look finally into this fabled era is amazing, and I look forward to the ending with a bit of sadness =/
 
1 - 7 of 7 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top